• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Gaetano’s the Original: Indulge in Classic Italian Cheesesteaks and More

At Gaetano’s the Original, we celebrate the heart and soul of authentic Italian cuisine right in Willingboro, NJ. Our story is rooted in a passion for crafting mouthwatering cheesesteaks and pizzas that pay homage to traditional recipes. Each dish, from our classic Cheese Steak Hoagie to the savory Jersey Steak, boasts rich flavors and hearty ingredients. With a welcoming ambiance perfect for families and friends, we take pride in offering takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating. Whether you're indulging in our decadent desserts or enjoying a meal while watching the game, we promise a delightful dining experience that feels like home.

Gaetano’s the Original at a glance

  • Address 498 Beverly Rancocas Rd Willingboro Township, NJ 08046 United States
  • Phone (609) 871-5588
  • Restaurant type Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Gaetano’s the Original: Reviews & Ratings

Julian Rodriguez
5

I'm here from Texas for work, I found this place online I wanted to try a little bit of everything so I got two smalls and a mini... if you've never been here, be warned... the sandwiches are enormous lol. Apparently everything isn't bigger in Texas. I ordered a cheese steak with hot peppers and onions a chicken parm and a meatball with pepperoni. I will be eating on the sandwiches for the next few days. Out of all the cheesesteaks I've had in the Philly area this is on par with everything else I've had... meatball was seasoned well and tender. Has the perfect amount of cheese. The hot peppers are just the righ amount of heat. My meatball and pepperoni is excellent. I Do you like that the meatballs are a little bit more dense than other places. Do not like the mushy textures so these are perfect for me. I'm too full from eating the meatball and Cheesesteak and have not tried the chicken parm. Photo is of the chicken parm I can't wait to try it

Bethany Lee
5

This place tucked away in Willingboro is definitely worth the visit. It gives off this "mom n pop" vibe: laid back, down home, TVs everywhere.. n just "chill." The food was AMAZING!!! We ordered roast beef fries and a 12" Texas hold em cheesesteak... 3 of us couldnt finish it. The cheesesteak was filled to the top. We drove over an hour to try this place and will MOST definitely come again!

alfredo torres
5

A small is huge!! Thats all i have to say i ordered the Mr Gees and i did not disappoint. Over all i think it a great cheesesteak spot.

A C
5

I usually order out but you can dine in and can’t beat their pie specials. Their sandwiches at Lee also huge and delicious! This review is for their pizza that was purchased a few weeks back. The portions are great, you don’t have to worry about not being fulfilled when you dine here. The food is always fresh and the service is fast.

Carmon Choice
5

News flash! The best cheesesteaks aren’t in Philly. The best cheesesteaks can be found right here at Gaetano’s in Willingboro, NJ! I drove all the way from Philadelphia for this experience and I could not be more pleased! If you want a great cheesesteak with fries cooked and seasoned to perfection, this is the place! You won’t be disappointed!

A. Anderson
5

Absolutely outstanding!!!....the buffalo fries w/blue cheese( made fresh in house) was my favorite next to the hot garlic parmesan wings...can't wait to visit again. Both our waitresses were lovely, pleasant, attentive, & happy....we drove allllll the way from NY. Worth it!!!!

Kevin Felton
5

They really a hearty and flavorful cheesesteak. I ordered a small one, which seemed like a large on to me. The service was great as well. I recommend this place if you do not feel like traveling to Philadelphia for a good cheesesteak.

King James
4

Not a bad spot at all. They give you nice size portions for your money. I ordered the mini cheese steak (which isn't small at all) and the toasted sesame wings. The pictures don't do it justice but the wings were very large and the "mini" cheese steak was bigger than what I expected. Both the wings and the cheese steak were very flavorful. If you're in the area definitely give this place a try.

Location

  • Gaetano’s the Original
    Gaetano’s the Original
    498 Beverly Rancocas Rd Willingboro Township, NJ 08046 United States Hotline: (609) 871-5588

Welcome to the flavorful world of Gaetano’s the Original, a beloved gem located in the heart of Willingboro Township, NJ. Specializing in cheesesteaks, pizza, and authentic Italian cuisine, Gaetano’s promises an unforgettable experience that caters to both casual diners and families alike.

As you step into this vibrant eatery, the welcoming atmosphere envelops you. With a moderate noise level and casual dress code, it's the perfect spot for both lunch and dinner. Your culinary adventure begins as you explore a diverse menu that includes tantalizing options such as:

  • Chicken Cheese Steak - A delightful twist on the classic, featuring fresh, quality ingredients.
  • Seafood Platters - A taste of the ocean with expertly prepared shrimp, flounder, and crab.
  • Pasta Dishes - Indulge in hearty spaghetti and meatballs or baked ziti that will warm your soul.

One of the standout offerings is the Jersey Chicken Steak with Cheese, which boasts a mouthwatering blend of flavors, including potatoes, green peppers, and a drizzle of barbecue sauce. It's a dish that pays homage to classic sandwich traditions while adding Gaetano's unique flair.

For seafood enthusiasts, the Fried Shrimp and Clam Combo is a must-try, delivering both crispiness and flavor that makes for a delightful meal. And let’s not overlook the Spinach Lasagna, a comforting favorite that harmonizes rich cheeses with perfectly cooked pasta.

Gaetano’s also offers the convenience of delivery and takeout, making it easy to enjoy these delicious dishes at home. Families can conveniently dine together, as the establishment accommodates groups and provides good options for kids. Additionally, their catering services make it an ideal choice for parties or gatherings.

Whether you’re looking to share a meal with friends over a glass of wine or enjoy a quiet dinner with family on their outdoor patio, Gaetano’s the Original stands out as the go-to spot for flavorful Italian dishes. Don’t forget to indulge in their delightful array of desserts to complete your meal.

Visit Gaetano’s the Original at 498 Beverly Rancocas Rd, Willingboro Township, NJ 08046 and experience the perfect blend of classic recipes and heartfelt service. For any inquiries, feel free to call them at (609) 871-5588. Your taste buds will surely thank you!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards